When shopping for walnuts, you might notice labels like English, Persian, or black walnuts and wonder what the difference between these options are. Various types of walnuts offer distinct flavors, textures, shell thicknesses, and even nutritional profiles. Understanding these differences helps you choose the right option for specific uses, whether snacking, cooking, or baking, and forms the foundation for learning about walnut varieties.
English Walnuts: The Most Common Variety
English walnuts, also called Persian walnuts or common walnuts, are one of the most common walnut varieties and the most familiar example of walnut varieties available worldwide. This category accounts for approximately 99% of commercial walnut production and represents what most people encounter in stores. Despite the name, English walnuts originated in ancient Persia (current-day Iran) before reaching England, making them one of the oldest cultivated walnut varieties.
These nuts are prized for their relatively thin, light-colored shells that crack easily and the mild, slightly sweet flavor of the kernel. They have blonde-colored shells and pale kernels with a taste that blends well in recipes for salads, desserts, bread, and soups. This versatility makes English walnuts the default choice for most culinary applications and a benchmark among walnut varieties.
The kernels display the characteristic pale ivory to light tan color that consumers are familiar with. The texture is creamy and buttery when fresh, making them pleasant to eat raw or roasted. These nuts contain approximately 65% fat, 15% protein, and 14% carbohydrates per 100 grams, with significant amounts of omega-3 fatty acids, a nutritional highlight among walnut varieties.
Several cultivars within this category have become popular. Chandler, Hartley, Howard, and Tulare represent the most widely planted options in California and are key examples of commercial walnut varieties. Chandler is frequently named the best for fresh eating due to its very light kernels, thin shell, and high yield.
Black Walnuts: The Bold Alternative
Black walnuts represent a distinctly different option from their English counterparts and stand out strongly among walnut varieties. Native to eastern North America, these nuts grow wild across much of the eastern and midwestern United States, though they're also cultivated commercially on a smaller scale, making them one of the more niche walnut varieties.
The most obvious difference is shell thickness. Black walnuts have distinctly black or streaky-black shells that are far tougher to crack than English types. This thick shell makes processing more challenging and contributes to higher prices for shelled nuts, a common trait noted when comparing walnut varieties.
The flavor profile sets this type apart dramatically. Black walnuts taste significantly stronger, richer, and more earthy than English versions. Some describe the flavor as bold, intense, or even slightly bitter. The deep, rich taste works particularly well in baking applications where the distinctive character adds complexity, setting these walnut varieties apart from milder ones.
Nutritionally, black walnuts offer a couple of advantages compared to English variants. They have substantially more protein, less carbs, sugars and fats per serving (around 30 grams), compared to English walnuts. This makes them a good option for people looking for a protein-packed nut and exploring nutrient-dense walnut varieties.
Lesser-Known Options
Beyond the dominant English and black walnut varieties, several other types exist that are worth understanding when learning about walnut varieties.
Heartnuts come from Japan and are gaining popularity in some regions. These produce heart-shaped, thin-shelled nuts that are easy to crack and enjoyable for fresh eating. Heartnuts are smaller trees than other types and represent one of the more unique walnut varieties available today.
Butternuts, also called white walnuts, are native to eastern North America. They produce elongated nuts with thick shells similar to black walnuts. The flavor is sweet and rich, often described as superior by those who enjoy them. Unfortunately, butternuts face serious disease pressure, making them increasingly rare, expensive and hard-to-find among walnut varieties.
Commercial Cultivars Within English Types
Within the broad category of English walnuts, specific cultivars have been developed for commercial production, further expanding the list of recognized walnut varieties.
Chandler ranks among the most popular globally. It produces large, light-colored kernels with excellent flavor and high yields. Chandler walnuts crack easily and have an attractive appearance, traits that make this cultivar a leader among walnut varieties.
Hartley represents older cultivars that remain popular due to reliability and consistent quality. These have been grown for decades and have proven adaptable to various growing conditions, which is why they remain relevant walnut varieties.
Howard was developed specifically for early harvest. These ripen sooner than many other cultivars, making them valuable in regions with shorter growing seasons and an important example of climate-adapted walnut varieties.
Franquette offers exceptional cold-resistance compared to other English types. These late-leafing nuts avoid late spring frosts that damage other options. Franquette walnuts have slightly thicker shells and more robust flavor when compared to other ones, distinguishing them among walnut varieties.
Discover Eatabbly Walnuts (150 gram jars)
How Different Types Affect Cooking
Choosing between options matters in the kitchen because they behave differently in recipes, which is why understanding walnut varieties is so useful. English walnuts work universally well in most applications. Their mild flavor doesn't overpower other ingredients, making them suitable for everything from salads to cakes.
Black walnuts require more consideration. Their intense flavor can dominate dishes if not used thoughtfully. In baking, they add distinctive character to brownies, cookies, and cakes, but they're not universally loved. When using black walnuts, consider reducing the amount or test recipes calling for English types before committing to a larger batch, as different walnut varieties can produce very different results.
For snacking, preferences vary by individual taste. English walnuts appeal to most people with their mild, creamy character. Black walnuts attract those who enjoy bold, distinctive flavors and don't mind working harder to crack the shells, a common tradeoff seen across walnut varieties.
Choosing the Right Type for Your Needs
When selecting walnuts, consider your primary use. For general snacking and cooking, English walnuts offer the best combination of versatility, availability, and ease of use. They're what you'll find in most stores, and their mild flavor works in virtually any application, which is why they dominate global walnut varieties.
If you enjoy distinctive, bold flavors and don't mind extra effort, black walnuts provide a unique taste experience. They're worth seeking out for special baking projects or when you specifically want that intense character found in certain walnut varieties.
Price differences reflect availability and processing difficulty. English walnuts cost less per kilogram due to their dominance in commercial production. Black walnuts command premium prices, often double or triple the cost of English types, a common pricing pattern among walnut varieties.
For Indian consumers specifically, most walnuts sold in India are English types, often imported from California or grown in Kashmir. Finding black walnuts in India requires specialty stores or online retailers, limiting access to some walnut varieties.
Finding Quality Options
Regardless of which type you choose, quality matters more than variety. The kernels should be plump rather than shriveled. When buying in-shell nuts, shake them near your ear. Fresh walnuts feel heavy and don't rattle much. Old, dried-out nuts often rattle noticeably because the kernels have shrunk away from the shell, an issue that can affect all walnut varieties.
You can find black walnut options from from Flipkart, and english varieties from local stores on online. Store all walnuts properly regardless of type. Keep them in airtight containers in cool, dark locations. For longer storage, refrigerate or freeze them to prevent the oils from going rancid, which is essential for preserving flavor across walnut varieties.
Making an Informed Choice
Understanding different walnut varieties helps you make informed choices about which types to buy and how to use them, especially when comparing walnut varieties side by side. English walnuts dominate the market for good reasons: they're versatile, mild-flavored, and easy to use. Black walnut, white and heartnuts offer bold flavor and nutritional advantages for those willing to work harder for their reward, rounding out the spectrum of walnut varieties.
Most people will find English walnuts perfectly suited to their needs. However, exploring black walnuts or other specialty options can expand your culinary horizons and introduce flavors you might not have experienced. The key is knowing what distinguishes these types and choosing based on your specific preferences and intended uses, which is the ultimate goal of understanding walnut varieties.
